The Institutional Risk Analyst

As of December 31, 2025, Athene had the ability to draw up to an estimated $30.7 billion via advances, inclusive of borrowings then outstanding. But when the funding agreements are added, the total exposure to the FHLBs from APO is over $50 billion vs $74 billion in total capital and retained earnings for the FHLB system.

Once again, the management of TWO seems to have managed to destroy shareholder value in great bloody chunks. Given that the mortgage servicing rights of TWO had a book value of $2.4 billion at the end of Q4, it seems fair to ask whether the best trade for TWO shareholders is to vote against the merger with UWMC and simply sell the MSR. 

The changes proposed by Governor Bowman, if made effective, will have a significant and very positive impact on banks and non-banks operating in the residential mortgage market.

Large-cap tech stocks experienced the worst week since November, causing a split market where value-oriented stocks are gaining attention, while tech stocks and crypto tokens are being liquidated. Equity managers are rotating out of tech and into everything else, creating a cosmic imbalance that is difficult for the non-tech equity market to absorb.

But the key factor that generated investor angst was under-performance in terms of loan recapture, an illustration of the hyper-competitive market in residential mortgages. True retention = Retained fundings divided by total run off. On that basis, we figure that PFSI retained less than 1/3 of mortgages that prepaid in Q4 2025. After touching $160 in late January, PFSI closed yesterday below $95 per share.

The addition of Kevin Warsh as Fed Chairman does not change the ST calculus on the FOMC in terms of support for further rate cuts. Even as a former Governor, Warsh begins his term as leader of a minority on the Committee, especially if former Chairman Powell remains on the Board. This is why the inability of Trump to blame Powell for the astronomical increase in home prices, as we discuss below, is so remarkable.

And as we predicted several months ago, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are at the bottom of the list now instead of the top, reflecting the fact that release from conservatorship has been shelved in favor of the GSEs buying back their own debt. Using the balance sheets of the GSEs to buy MBS basically makes them instruments of public policy, but this does not preclude President Trump from directing an equity offering after the midterm elections.

President Donald Trump, Bill Pulte and Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick have apparently met a couple of times in recent weeks to consider policy initiatives for spurring housing. Meanwhile, the GSEs have begun to buy and/or retain mortgage assets in an effort to push down mortgage rates, an effort that is unlikely to have much effect.

Only the Fed under Janet Yellen was dumb enough to buy $3 trillion in MBS, costing the taxpayer hundreds of billions in losses without really affecting mortgage rates. A mere $200 billion from Donald Trump is a rounding error, pure populist political pulp -- another progressive political display that will have zero impact on LT interest rates. In fact, the childish suggestions coming from the White House on housing may continue to push LT interest rates up.

Kevin Hassett's comments on Federal Reserve independence may have undercut his chances for the top Fed job. President Donald Trump has observed in recent days that there are “two Kevins,” Hassett and former Fed governor Kevin Warsh, who we personally support.

“The delinquency rate for commercial mortgages increased in the second quarter of 2025 across most major capital sources,” said Reggie Booker, MBA’s Associate Vice President of Commercial Real Estate Research. “The largest increase was among CMBS loans, driven by rising delinquencies in both multifamily and office properties. Delinquency trends continue to reflect differences in property type, loan structure, geography, and borrower profile.”

PFSI trades on a trailing P/E of 14x vs ~ 8x for RITM. PFSI trades around 1.6x book vs 0.9x for RITM. Case closed? We have long believed that RITM should spin off its manager to create a comp for PFSI and then externally manage the RITM REIT. Like PFSI, in this scenario the new RITM manager would need to retain the Ginnie Mae MSRs.

Does the Trump White House understand that the professional staff of the GSEs are preparing to roll out yet another capital increase for the residential housing market in 2025? Does Director Pulte understand that the changes are being advanced by the staffs of the GSEs in his name and with his apparent support? We suspect that the answer is no.

Hedge fund mogul Bill Ackman changed his tune and told investors this week that the government should not hurry to release Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac from government conservatorship. This announcement is essentially window dressing on the part of Ackman after FHFA Director Bill Pulte announced that the GSEs would not be released from conservatorship, dashing the hope of long-suffering shareholders.

We expect the shares of the GSEs to lose ground this week given last week’s bizarre announcement by Federal Housing Finance Agency Director Bill Pulte that the GSEs will not be released from conservatorship after all. After pumping the two stocks for months with the prospect of release from conservatorship, Pulte said Friday that the GSEs would stay under federal control for now, reinforcing their conservatorship status while exploring a limited public offering option.

The latest statements about a possible stock offering for the GSEs seem to be designed to boost the share price in the near-term and do not provide any more information than we had when such statements were made previously.  Given the management changes announced yesterday and the other requirements for a successful offering, we have a hard time believing that a GSE stock offering will occur this year.  Notice how the shares of Fannie Mae popped for a couple of days this week

The accumulation of delinquent loans in the mortgage complex since COVID has gotten to the point where residential loan defaults have no place to go but up. Higher delinquency levels will enable investors to pay less for mortgage loans in the secondary markets, adding to cash losses per loan that are already several points vs the loan balance.  It's not about "gain on sale" but rather cash received.

So why would a firm like CrossCountry or UWMC be a buyer of higher coupon MSRs?  The short answer is that they believe their ability to retain the borrower by recapturing a prepayment will offset the obvious negative of high prepayments that comes with a lower interest rate environment.  These firms, it seems, would rather try to recapture prepayments on higher rate MSRs than own lower coupons and benefit from the stable cash flow from the servicing.

Q: Do you suppose the folks inside the Trump White House, who spend much of the day watching Newsmax, understand that loan forbearance is about to end for tens of thousands of American households on October 1st?

Why is FHFA Director Bill Pulte being excluded from the process of preparing the GSEs for release from conservatorship? Short answer is that Bessent and the professional staff at Treasury don’t think that the very high profile Pulte (aka "Little Trump") should be involved. But this may be a serious error in judgment by Scott Bessent.